Implications for cognition, emotion, and motivation, authorhazel rose markus and shinobu kitayama, year 1991. The intersection of culture and achievement motivation. According to markus and kitayama 1991, although european north ameri cans are more likely to have independent selfconstruals and therefore to value. She is also a founder and faculty director of stanford sparq, a do tank that partners with industry leaders to tackle disparities and inspire culture change using insights from behavioral. It is suggested that perceptions of the self, of others, and of the relationship between self and others are very powerful and that this influence is clearly reflected in culture. Evaluation of theoretical assumptions and metaanalyses daphna oyserman, heather m. According to markus and kitayama according to markus and. In contrast, those with an interdependent selfconstrual define themselves in terms of their relationships with others. Markus and icitayama 1991 in their analysis of the difference between american and japanese selfconstruals. In japan, the nail that stands out gets pounded down. Implications for cognition, emotion, and markus, h.
In contrast, eastern cultures conventionally construe and construct the self as a constituentof a broader social con. Zajonc collegiate professor of psychology and the director of the center for culture, mind, and the brain. In this sense, culture and mind are mutually reinforcing. Peoples participation in local culture shapes their psyches, which in turn creates their cultural environment. The article discusses divergent aspects of the self by arguing that western and eastern cultures hold divergent construals of the self, of others, and of the relationship between the two the self and others. Hazel rose markus and shinobu kitayama ily the product. Individuals engaging with these contexts are strongly motivated to con. This definition has been applied to characterize cultural differences in emotion, motivation, and the self, with some cultures favoring interdependenceviewing the self as connected to others and empha. It is important to note that, although selforientation and otherorientation are often seen as opposite poles of a single dimension, the two constructs are conceptually distinct and may coexist e.
The suicide of a cyberbullied student prompted the schoolaged authors of this article to administer a child abuse prevention services survey to 587 students in. Reproductions supplied by edrs are the best that can be made. Implications for cognition, emotion, and motivation. Implications for cognition, emotion and motivation. Originally from japan, shinobu kitayama received his ph. The article compares an independent view of the self. Culture, selfconstrual, and leisure theory and practice nrpa. This perspective can make a contribution to some contemporary controversies in personality. Given the time constraint, limited reflection provided. According to markus and kitayamas 1991 theory, westerners per.
Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. Lower class individualswho have reduced objective resources to rely onmay exhibit more otheroriented patterns of emotion e. A cultural perspective on functional limitations and well. People in different cultures have strikingly different construals of the self, of others, and of the interdepe hazel rose markus, shinobu kitayama psychological. Hazel rose markus and shinobu kitayama, culture and the. The cultural psychology of personality hazel rose markus. Sherman university of california, santa barbara whereas selfexpression is valued in the u. An empirical assessment of markusand kitayama s theory of independent and interdependent selfconstruals davidmatsumoto san francisco state university in this paper, i critically evaluate the logic underlying markus and kitayama s 1991 theory of independent and interdependent selfconstruals, and examine. Effects of selfconstrual and its relationship with subjective well. In 1991, markus and kitayama published an article that focused on a fundamental question of psychologynamely, the relationship between the individual self. Culture and the effect of selfexpression on choice heejung s. Kitayama, markus, tummala, kurokawa, and kato 1990 examined this idea in a study requiring similarity judgments between self and other. S kitayama, hr markus, h matsumoto, v norasakkunkit. The ones marked may be different from the article in the profile.
Implications for cognition, emotion, and motivation some notesdirect quotes i took from markus and kitayama 1991. When considering that statement i would say that my selfconstrual. Four studies demonstrate the psychological implications of this cultural difference. Pdf people in different cultures have strikingly different construals of the self. To date, much of this work has addressed the influence of individualism or collectivism, often framed in terms of independent vs. Therefore, a satisfactory understanding of human psychology requires. People in different cultures have strikingly different construals of the self, of others, and of the interdependence of the 2. An empirical assessment of markusand kitayamas theory of independent and interdependent selfconstruals davidmatsumoto san francisco state university in this paper, i critically evaluate the logic underlying markus and kitayamas 1991 theory of independent and interdependent selfconstruals, and examine. One is independent, and the other is interdependent. Markus and kitayama 1991 suggested that an individual should have two distinct selfconstruals. Consistent with this relativity hypothesis, heine and colleagues have argued that the need for positive regardis not universal, but rather. The effects of selfconstruals, selfcriticism, and selfcompassion on. Social class, solipsism, and contextualism 547 this document is ed by the american psychological association or one of its.
A cultural analysis heejung kim and hazel rose markus stanford university uniqueness has positive connotations of freedom and independence in american culture, whereas conformity has positive connotations of connectedness and harmony in east asian culture. I critically evaluate the logic underlying markus and kitayamas 1991 theory of independent and interdependent self. Hazel rose markus and shinobu kitayama, culture and the self. According to markus and kitayama 1991, those with an independent selfconstrual define themselves in terms of internal attributes such as traits, abilities, values, and preferences. She is the davisbrack professor in the behavioral sciences at stanford university in stanford, california. Markus and kitayama 1991 found that western cultures tend to construe the self as separate from its social context, and thus emphasize autonomy and. In addition, individualism and collectivism have been associated with a number of important psychological variables, including selfesteem, wellbeing, communication styles, social explanation processes, and social behavior oyserman et al. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. Research in cultural psychology suggests that person is a social and collective construction made possible through an individuals participation in the practices and meanings of a given cultural context. Many asian cultures have distinct conceptions of individuality that insist on the fundamental relatedness of. Markus and kitayama 1991 found that western cultures tend to construe the self as separate from its social context, and thus emphasize autonomy and independence, which is independent selfconstrual.
In this paper, i critically evaluate the logic underlying markus and kitayamas 1991 theory of independent and interdependent self. Triandis, 1995, and given that most models of shame and guilt are based on western samples, it is likely that the. Cultural differences in the use of criticism and praise as motivators it is standard wisdom in the canon of western child rearing that children. From the beginning, americans have been enjoined to value life, liberty, and the pursuit of. Triandis, 1990, 1995, contexts fostering the perception that one is acting in accordance with the dictates and wishes of others in ones social ingroup will be integrally linked to their intrinsic motivation. Views of cultures as static andor stable have been disrupted by global demographic, economic, and. Implications for survey research shinobu kitayama university of michigan.
Given the significant body of research that has demonstrated that u. Furthermore, cultural representation is valued regarding its fit to the expected, mandated way within a given culture, however, individuals will vary in the extent to which they are good cultural representatives and construe the self in the mandated way markus and kitayama, 1991. Hazel rose markus is a social psychologist and a pioneer in the field of cultural psychology. Cultural variation in the selfconcept springerlink. And although there exist many interesting psychological differences between east asian subcultures e. In the current article, it is argued that although most conceptions. Markus and kitayama 1991 contend that anecdotes like these symbolize meaningful and important cultural differences between the u. These construals can influence, and in many cases determine, the very nature of individual experience, including cognition, emotion, and motivation. People in different cultures have strikingly different construals of the self, of others, and of. The proposition that cultures which differ in their social orientation independence vs.
937 137 461 1194 586 57 675 1162 877 1253 1330 16 1039 404 784 1112 833 1 12 1182 1030 1195 632 472 1140 107 861 991 145 1294 559 824 1265 1480 211 1357 1255 202